when you get to the muffling aspect of bassdrums, its all about personal preference. Many people like a Dry sound, and they add more foam to the drums. While others like less foam for more of a sustained sound.
Theres really no wrong way about muffling a bassdrum, i have my own method in which i foam, and tune my basses, and its worked well with the HS lines, Indoor and Drumcorps line i have taught.
i go to
www.foamonline.com Click on rectangular shaped Foam.
Type in the Length [ pi(d) ], Width (3" or 15"), and Height (at the bottom of this post)
for indoor: 15" wide or 17" depending on the width of some of the wider bottom basses. (that way it sticks out 1/2" from both sides and you make sure that its touching both heads. and it covers the whole inner shell of the drum.)
for outdoor: Two 3" wide strips per drum
height (thickness):
16- 1"
18- 1"
20- 1.5"
22- 1.5"
24- 2"
26- 2"
28- 2.5"
30- 2.5"
32- 3"
then the length you would have to do the Pi x D formula.
if the drums sound too dry, you can always take an exacto knife and cut the foam to ur liking....if your line does indoor....i HIGHLY recommend the foam all the way around.
I like my bassdrums dry with little sust ains, but enough for the tone to cut through. Reason being, I am very anal about how my basslines play, and if they're going to make mistakes. I want everyone to hear it. And I want the judges to catch it too, so that they can be called out. The drier the drum, the more exposed they are, and the easier it is to tell what type of notes theyre playing. Instead of just hearing all tone and no impacts.
the Thickness is what is listed with the 1"-3"
the width is how wide the foam will be, that is glued to the inner shell...
the Length is how long you want it...if you want it to go all the way around the inner shell of the drum you will use the formula i listed:
Pi x D = 3.14 multiplied by the diameter of the drum...
for example for a 16" bass drum you will do-
3.14 x 16" = 50.24" thats how long the foam would be...
so:
L= 50.24"
W= 3"
Height (thickness) - 1"
Buy 2 strips and drum 1 is done.
now go to the next...18"
3.14x18 = and so on.
when you plug the numbers into the website, you will click add to cart and make sure you order 2 of this. Since you will need two 3" strips per side of each drum...
it shouldnt cost more than $40...which is a steal compared to how much you would spend per pack of
Yamaha or
Pearl foam that can only be used once. This foam you buy to your specific liking and ur good to go....
oh VERY IMPORTANT...make sure you order HIGH DENSITY FOAM under the foam type heading..... and for firmness Medium Soft.
The Spray Glue is 3M Super 77.
As far as Tuning goes...
I go with a pretty simple method. I'm not the type that grabs a tuner and tunes to any specific pitch. It takes too much time and musically, unless the show you're playing is in 5 notes, just isn't worth it in my opinion.
I get my desired Drop (tone) of Bottom bass, and the tune up from there. I tune to perfect 4ths or.. the "Here comes the bride" technique. This way, drums 1 3 & 5 are the same note but different octaves and 2 &4 are same the same note but different octaves. Plus you have a nice equal interval between drums and it covers the ranges you would want.
Next thing...heads....
My personal preference is the Remo Emperor. Yes..this is a 2 ply head. these heads are very crankable and sound very good when muffled correctly and tuned correctly.
I also like the Remo Ambassador heads. My only issue is the life span of these heads. Since theyre 1-ply heads, they only sound good for a certain period of time. If you have a hard hitting bassline, like I do, then these heads aren't for you.
We just removed the Evans heads from the basses at the HS i teach. The heads sound EXCELLENT. But like the ambassadors..dont last too long...Plus i hate the muffling system. Good idea...but doesnt work too well. You will always get a buzzing sound from the lower drums. (yes..i've done it correctly)
The next heads on my list are the New Remo Powermax heads...i hear they have the same style system as the evans heads, but more thought out.